BRP Blog

Maximizing Gym Member Retention Through Effective Management Systems

David Hult
<span id="hs_cos_wrapper_name" class="hs_cos_wrapper hs_cos_wrapper_meta_field hs_cos_wrapper_type_text" style="" data-hs-cos-general-type="meta_field" data-hs-cos-type="text" >Maximizing Gym Member Retention Through Effective Management Systems</span>

Retention is one of the most important things that decides how profitable a gym chain is, and it is also the area where the management system can make the biggest difference. Here is what we see working, and what to look for when you review your platform.

Between 30 and 50% of members leave their club every year, depending on market and niche. When I talk to gym chains about this, most of them know their churn figure well, but fewer have a clear picture of why members leave, when they start to drift away and what the chain could have done differently in those weeks.

That gap is where the management system comes in. Every percentage point of retention is worth a great deal to a chain, because the effect is multiplied across every club and every month. Keeping a member is also much cheaper than winning a new one, which makes retention one of the most profitable things a chain can invest in.

 

Members rarely leave overnight

In our experience, most members give signals long before they cancel. They come to the club less often, they stop booking classes, they skip the PT session they used to look forward to, or a payment fails and nobody follows it up. Each signal on its own is easy to miss, especially in a chain with many clubs and thousands of members, but together they tell a clear story.

A system that only records the cancellation when it arrives is telling you what has already happened. What chains need is a platform that picks up those early signals, combines them into a picture of each member and triggers the right action at the right time, preferably automatically so that nobody has to remember to do it.

 

Engagement that is built into the member experience

The chains that keep members longest tend to give them reasons to come back that go beyond the training itself. Loyalty programmes with tiers and rewards, challenges and streaks that make progress visible, refer-a-friend campaigns that bring training partners into the club, and a member app in the chain's own brand where all of this comes together.

Gamification and challenges work particularly well because they turn the habit of training into something members can see and share. When those tools live inside the management system, they can be based on real visits, bookings and training data, and they are easy to run across every club at once. When they live in separate tools, they tend to be used less, measured less and forgotten when the person who set them up moves on.

 

Marketing automation that keeps the dialogue going

The first weeks of a membership are often the most important. A new member who gets a warm welcome, a booked introduction session and a nudge to try a class is far more likely to build a routine than one who simply receives a receipt.

Marketing automation makes it possible to keep that dialogue going from the first visit to renewal, without adding work for staff in the clubs. Welcome flows, reminders when visits drop, invitations to challenges, birthday greetings and offers before a commitment period ends can all run automatically, based on segments and behaviour. Whether the automation is native to the platform or connected through a seamless integration matters less than that it works with the same member data as everything else.

 

Do not forget the members who never meant to leave

Some members leave without ever deciding to. Their card expires, a direct debit fails, and if nothing happens the membership quietly lapses. Fitness companies lose around 11% of revenue to failed payments, according to a survey reported by PYMNTS, and part of that loss is members who would happily have stayed.

This is one of the easiest areas to improve. Automated retries, reminders with a payment link, automatic updates of card details when a card expires or is replaced, and a clear hand-over to a collection partner when needed can recover a large share of those members without anyone at reception having to chase them.

 

What to look for in a new system

When you review your platform, I would look closely at how it handles the whole retention journey rather than individual features. A few questions worth asking every vendor are how the system identifies members at risk of leaving and which actions can be automated, how loyalty programmes, challenges and refer-a-friend work in practice and what results other customers have seen, and how automated sales funnels and marketing automation connect to the same member data.

It is also worth asking how the platform connects with the wider fitness ecosystem, such as digital wellness machine software and smart circuit training apps and machines. Training data from those sources makes it much easier to see who is engaged and who is drifting away.

 

Before you start, collect your baseline

The most useful thing you can do before talking to any vendor is to collect your own numbers, so that you have something to measure the new system against.

 

Data to collect

  • Churn and retention levels per club, region and country over the past 12–24 months

  • Average length of membership and the most common reasons for cancelling

  • Share of members active in loyalty programmes, challenges and refer-a-friend

  • Share of cancellations that follow a failed payment

 

Goals to set

  • Target retention level and length of membership in three years

  • The churn signals that should trigger automated actions, and through which channels

  • How many members you want to recover from failed payments

 

Retention is one of five drivers we describe in our BRP Guide How gym chains procure the right management system. The guide also covers how to write requirements, evaluate vendors and compare total cost, and you can download it here

Download the full guide here!

Sources

1. PYMNTS – Health and fitness companies lose 11% of revenues to failed payments – https://www.pymnts.com/subscriptions/2023/health-fitness-companies-lose-11-percent-revenues-failed-payments/